Sophia Couzos and Richard Murray, editors (for the
Kimberley Aboriginal Medical Services Council). 2nd
ed.
Melbourne: Oxford University Press; 2003.
Anybody who read or used the first edition of
Couzos and Murray's book1
will recall that it represented a vast amount of
work by many individuals. People who work in
clinical medicine will also know how quickly
such a collection of evidence can become dated.
The second edition of 'Aboriginal primary health
care: an evidence-based approach' is therefore
welcome and impressive. There are new sections,
expanded sections, and all sections have been
updated.
The book aims to be a reference for organisations
regarding defined Aboriginal health issues. It also
serves as a guide to clinical practice through
explicit supported statements, while recognising the
desirability of local adaptation of advice and
essential 'respectful engagement with the local
knowledge and experience of Indigenous people'.
The whole book is a product of the experience of
Indigenous people, beginning with the first chapter
'Aboriginal health and the policy process'.
Recognising his wisdom and legacy, each chapter is
prefaced by a quote from the late Dr Puggy Hunter, a
long-time chairman of the National Aboriginal
Community Controlled Health Organisation. The book
demonstrates that to be involved in Aboriginal
primary health care is to be involved in a struggle
for self-determination and community identity, and
it successfully presents both the clinical evidence
and the imperative to respect, recognise and promote
autonomy and self-value among patients as
foundations of good health care.
While the book is lengthy - at more than 600 pages it
is about half as long again as the 1999 edition,
with bigger pages - its structure assists in finding
desired information. As with the first edition, each
chapter concerned with a specific condition begins
with a summary. This is expanded upon in the pages
that follow, in a systematic order: goals and
targets (published statements of intent relating to
that condition), burden of disease, risk factors,
case definition, diagnostic procedures,
effectiveness of prevention, implementation of
programs, data collection and, for most, performance
indicators. References and notes are at the end of
the chapters. Each chapter has shaded boxes of key
points, which I found added to the presentation of
the information.
Importantly, the second edition has chapters on
substance abuse, custodial health and suicide and
self-harm, recognising tragic realities for many
Aboriginal people and communities. In these and
other chapters the book successfully injects
evidence about the mediating effect that
socio-economic and other determinants of health
(such as history, ethnicity, geography) might have
in health outcomes, and provides practical advice
about how to practise optimally given those
considerations. Notably, a National Health and
Medical Research Council review on the use of
socio-economic evidence in clinical practice
guidelines found that the first edition of this book
and other related guidelines were one of only two
sets of guidelines worldwide into which evidence
about the socio-economic determinants of health had
been incorporated.2
The book's use of evidence, ease of access despite
the complexity of information and its courage in
grappling with difficult issues make this book a
resource which no primary healthcare practitioner
should be without.