Prepared by J.W.G. Tiller, Department of Psychiatry, University of Melbourne, Royal Melbourne Hospital, Melbourne
Case
A 78 year old man who has had a longstanding sleep disorder presents for a review. He says that each morning he finds he has urinated on the floor during the night, although he has no recollection of this. His elderly wife reports that he often seems very confused at night and on a couple of occasions he has had episodes of nocturnal wandering and getting lost in the house. During the day he is alert, rational and oriented, and not confused. His memory 'is not what it was'. On a number of occasions he has forgotten why he went to the shops, so now he always uses a written shopping list.
After retirement he had had a problem with insomnia. His doctor had prescribed 25 mg of amitriptyline which had helped for some time. When the insomnia recurred, the dose was increased to 50 mg, which he took for the following 12 years. He usually had a brandy nightcap.
On examination, there were no significant clinical findings. There was no evidence of depression or dementia, although the patient was apprehensive about what was happening to him during the night. He had a prostatectomy 11 years ago because of a marked increase in urinary problems, particularly hesitancy. There was a postural drop in blood pressure of 10 mm Hg on standing, which rapidly recovered.
A progressive reduction of amitriptyline, firstly to 25 mg at night for a week, then stopping it, was associated with a manifest worsening of insomnia, which partly settled over 4-6 weeks with counselling and the use of nonpharmacological techniques to encourage sleep. The nighttime confusion and urination ceased.
Comment
Insomnia is common in the elderly. More than 25% may complain of symptoms of severe insomnia. It is important to evaluate the patient to see that insomnia is not due to depression, anxiety, pain (e.g. arthritis), physical illness or adverse drug effects. In elderly men, prostatic obstruction and the need to pass urine can disturb sleep. Therefore, it is useful to ask what settles or disturbs the patient through the night.
In the majority of cases, there is no significant cause of insomnia. In these cases, it is useful to discuss the reduced requirement for sleep in older people and introduce nonpharmacological techniques.1 Perseverance with a nonpharmacological approach will often produce satisfactory results within 4-6 weeks.
The hypnotics of choice, when indicated for short term use, are benzodiazepines. However, recent publicity and antibenzodiazepine campaigns have made many doctors reluctant to prescribe these drugs and some patients are unwilling to take them. Zopiclone may be an alternative.
The sedative tricyclic antidepressants are now in vogue as alternatives to benzodiazepines when a hypnotic is needed. However, the sedative tricyclics are appreciably more toxic than benzodiazepines.
In this case, the use of a tricyclic may have precipitated a worsening of urinary hesitancy leading to the prostatectomy. The anticholinergic effects can also add to confusion in the elderly, especially at night, while the alpha adrenergic blocking actions of the tricyclics can result in postural hypotension with the risks of falls and injuries. There is a rapid development of tolerance to the sedative effect of the tricyclics. Within two weeks, patients will tolerate doses of tricyclic antidepressants which would have caused excessive sedation when the treatment was started. There are no studies showing long term hypnotic efficacy, and the efficacy in the short term is mainly confined to data on depressive illness.
Antidepressants have a role in the treatment of insomnia only when associated with depression. On stopping sedative tricyclics, a withdrawal syndrome may occur with rebound insomnia, an increase in dreaming, and some daytime agitation and anxiety. These symptoms usually settle within about 4 weeks.
The patient should be advised about the effects of alcohol. Alcohol, if taken in sufficient quantities, may assist a patient getting off to sleep, but is associated with waking a few hours later. Its diuretic effect can also cause wakefulness and its effects on cognitive function can also lead to nocturnal confusion.
- Elderly patients with insomnia should be assessed for underlying treatable disorders.
- Instruct the patient in nonpharmacological techniques to assist the self management of insomnia.
- Consider occasional short term use of a benzodiazepine, or zopiclone, on an intermittent basis if insomnia is causing particular problems at certain times.
- Do not use low-dose sedative antidepressants as a hypnotic in otherwise uncomplicated insomnia.