Summary
The TGA has released an analysis of rotavirus vaccine and the risk of intussusception. A detailed report of the analysis, and links to fact sheets for parents and immunisation providers, are available from the TGA website (www.tga.gov.au).
The TGA, in collaboration with state health authorities, has undertaken an investigation of a possible association between the rotavirus vaccines Rotarix (GSK) and RotaTeq (Merck/CSL) and the occurrence of a rare form of bowel obstruction known as intussusception. Intussusception is a condition caused by the telescoping of one segment of the bowel into another. It is estimated to occur each year in around 80 per 100 000 children under 12 months of age, which represents approximately 200 cases per year in Australia. The peak incidence is in infants 5–10 months of age, with 80% of cases occurring before 24 months of age. It is much more common in males than females.
Intussusception was found to be an adverse effect of the first generation rotavirus vaccine (RotaShield, Wyeth) that was available in the US in 1998–99. RotaShield was estimated to cause intussusception in 10–20 of every 100 000 doses given to infants, and was voluntarily withdrawn in October 1999.4,5RotaShield was not used outside the US; however, as the historical incidence of intussusception is 2.5 to 3 times higher in infants in Australia than in the US, this would have translated to 25–60 cases of intussusception for every 100 000 doses of RotaShield if the vaccine had been used here.
Subsequently two new rotavirus vaccines, Rotarix and RotaTeq, were developed. Both were tested in large studies designed to explore the risk of intussusception. In each of these placebo-controlled preregistration studies, approximately 35 000 infants were given rotavirus vaccine, with no increased risk of intussusception observed.6,7However, as large preregistration safety studies may not always detect rare events, postmarketing studies have been undertaken in a number of countries.
In Australia, two postmarketing studies have been conducted to investigate whether the new rotavirus vaccines are associated with an increased risk of intussusception. The first study used two surveillance systems – the Paediatric Enhanced Disease Surveillance with active surveillance of intussusception cases in four tertiary centres, and the Australian Paediatric Surveillance Unit with national retrospective reporting of intussusception cases by paediatricians. This study, conducted in NSW, Victoria, WA and SA, found an apparent four-fold increased risk of intussusception in babies within one week of being given the first dose of either vaccine, compared with historical data on hospitalisations coded as intussusception, but no overall increase in overall rates of intussusception up to the age of 9 months. This is much lower than the risk found with the earlier RotaShield vaccine.
Following this, a large self-controlled case series study using data on all hospitalised cases coded as intussusception from NSW, Victoria and WA was commissioned by the TGA. This study found a statistically significant four-fold increase in the occurrence of intussusception in the first 1–7 days following the first dose of either Rotarix or RotaTeq compared with other time periods after vaccine receipt. This increase in risk translates to approximately two additional cases of intussusception occurring in every 100 000 first doses of vaccine, or six additional cases each year in children under 12 months of age in Australia.These findings are preliminary, as the data are subject to confirmation.
It is currently unclear whether this represents a true increase in overall risk of intussusception, or an early increase in risk in infants which is compensated for by a subsequent decrease in risk leading to a reduction in cases of intussusception in older children. Longer-term studies are required to clarify this.
Prior to the introduction of rotavirus vaccine, there were an estimated 10 000 hospitalisations annually in children under five years due to rotavirus gastroenteritis. Since the introduction of Rotarix and RotaTeq onto the National Immunisation Program, emergency department visits for acute gastroenteritis in young children have declined and hospitalisations for rotavirus gastroenteritis in the under-5-years age group have been reduced by over 70%.8,9Based on the established benefits of rotavirus vaccination and the rare occurrence of intussusception, both the World Health Organization and the Australian Technical Advisory Group on Immunisation have recommended the continued use of rotavirus vaccine for infants under the National Immunisation Program.