Prescribing wellness: comprehensive pain management outside specialist services
- Simon Holliday, Chris Hayes, Lester Jones, Jill Gordon, Newman Harris, Michael Nicholas
- Aust Prescr 2018;41:86-91
- 1 June 2018
- DOI: 10.18773/austprescr.2018.023
Opioids have important roles in the time-limited treatment of acute and cancer pain, end-of-life pain or dyspnoea, and in opioid dependency.
Maintaining focus on biomedical treatments, including drugs, has limited success in chronic pain.
Active self-management and healthy lifestyle choices are fundamental to addressing multisystem complexity and harnessing neuroplasticity in chronic pain.
Addressing psychosocial maladaptations and physical deconditioning requires a variety of approaches, frequently involving multiple care providers.
In practice, most pain care is delivered outside specialist centres by GPs and other non-pain specialists. Although they are well placed to provide multimodal care, they often lack training and confidence in delivering this care.
Codeine rescheduling in February 2018 prevented consumers accessing over-the-counter opioids without a prescription.1 This presents a major challenge because of the number of patients involved – over 15 million packs of over-the-counter opioid analgesics were purchased in Australia in 2013, accounting for 36.6% of total opioid pack sales.2
Chronic pain is defined as pain lasting beyond the time of tissue healing or for over three months.3 Almost half of GP consultations involve some discussion of pain, usually relegated behind comorbidities such as obesity and diabetes or psychiatric and substance-use disorders.4,5 Chronic pain challenges classic models of diagnosis and treatment.
Trials indicate that the best care for chronic pain involves self-management by the patient and a multidisciplinary approach through a pain centre rather than GP ‘treatment as usual’.6-9 However, a large US outpatient study found that only 0.12% of chronic pain consultations involved pain specialists.10 While less expensive, GP care does not become cost effective until it addresses physical disability alongside pain-related thoughts, emotions and behaviours.11 However, GPs have the advantage of capacity, accessibility (geographical and financial) and the potential to provide longitudinal, holistic and opportunistic care.7 For this reason, it is important GPs do not feel that treating chronic pain simply requires a choice between prescribing opioids or referring to specialist care.
Multimodal, multidisciplinary chronic pain care can be translated into time-poor primary care settings. Practice policies, holistic assessment then drug and non-drug approaches need to be explored.
A proactive pain management approach that begins at the reception desk can encourage optimum care. Suitable practice policies include refusing phone scripts, ensuring continuity of care with one doctor, displaying a sign about the opioid policy, and using Medicare items that support complex and collaborative care.
Even in acute pain, standard care is enhanced by a broad, ‘whole person’ assessment. The psychosocial dimension includes assessment of mood, cognitions, trauma, suicide risk and the social context of the presenting problems (e.g. workers’ compensation, family issues). Additional components incorporate physical activity, sleep patterns, nutrition, and past or current use of addictive substances including prescription drugs. Practice nurses can play a role in implementing time‑efficient assessments of chronic pain.
Practical steps for assessment include:
Guidelines for using opioids to treat pain have changed markedly, with prescription now being recommended only for acute pain, active cancer pain or palliative care. There is evidence to support long-term opioids as substitution therapy to minimise harm from dependency in opioid use disorders.
Prescribing opioids for over a week for acute pain doubles the risk of long-term use at one year (6% to 13%) and this risk doubles again (to 29.9%) if the initial prescription lasts a month.17 Dispensing in Australia increased 15-fold between 1992 and 2012, predominantly reflecting long-term opioid provision for chronic pain.18
The absence of long-term efficacy data has finally been addressed in a landmark randomised controlled trial of long-term opioids compared to non-opioid medicines for chronic musculoskeletal pain. During a year of collaborative care, the initiation of opioids failed to improve function, but caused more adverse effects and marginally worse pain intensity.19
Adverse effects include opioid-induced hyperalgesia and tolerance which cause a perceived increase in pain and need for dose escalation. Recent animal and human studies indicate that opioids may actually contribute directly to chronic pain. This toxicity may commence after brief exposure and leave a vulnerability to increased pain responses that may be of indefinite duration.20 Other long-term opioid toxicities include depression, sleep interference, hypogonadism, prolonged disability and delayed return to work.21-23
Suggested strategies to mitigate the risk of addiction (i.e. universal precautions) resemble an assortment of opioid substitution therapy approaches. However, these strategies fail to reliably predict or identify abusers or mitigate risks,3,6 and are rarely implemented by GPs.24 When initiated with dose reduction, risk mitigation strategies do not worsen pain control or quality of life.25
In general, introducing multimodal chronic pain care will facilitate opioid tapering or cessation and so improve pain outcomes and lower opioid-related risks both to patients and, when diverted, to their social network.26 GPs need to first estimate total opioid dose in morphine equivalents using conversion tables.27 Starting at a lower equivalent dose when rotating or simplifying regimens will reduce the risk of overdose. The deprescribing process may prove challenging – gradual weaning may be derailed by an abstinence syndrome involving insomnia, emotional blunting, deficits in executive control and the exacerbation or re-emergence of comorbid psychiatric disorders.28 If an attempt at deprescribing has been unsuccessful, it may be wise to plan a slower taper or consider opioid substitution therapy.
It is unwise to assume that new patients already taking opioids have a continuing need for opioid prescription. Difficult conversations may follow as doctors explain why opioids are no longer recommended for chronic pain. The requirement to comply with relevant state or territory regulations is protective in this setting.29 In some cases, providing limited dispensing and ‘methadone-style’ supervision may help to minimise harms such as abuse or overdose. It is important to consider safety strategies such as take-home naloxone for patients and families,30 fentanyl patch exchanges6 and the avoidance of benzodiazepine co-prescription.3,6
Patients consider meaningful chronic pain relief equates to at least 50% reduction in pain intensity. A systematic review found medicines, opioids or otherwise, do not achieve this for most patients.31 This finding was endorsed recently by a Canadian review of the limited evidence for non-opioid analgesics which included non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, antidepressants and antiepileptics such as pregabalin and gabapentin.6
As well as practising evidence-based medicine, doctors should identify and stop harmful or ineffective therapies. Regular pain reviews facilitate the early deprescribing of ineffective medicines.31
Recent concepts of pain look past any nociceptive (damaged tissue) or neuropathic (damaged nerve) contributors, to the role of brain interpretation, central sensitisation, descending modulation and immune and endocrine activation.32-34 The interpretation of pain by the brain involves encoding of signals from multiple sources and is more likely to occur when the person perceives a threat or danger. The pain experience is dampened or amplified by the dopamine (reward) system and the limbic system (emotions, motivations, learning and memory). Current theorists conceptualise pain as a warning system that consciously or unconsciously selects which behaviours will ensure the survival of the individual or their tribe.35
We need to educate patients that, just as their chronic pain is not a simple readout of the severity of tissue damage, their pain management must move beyond a narrow sensory focus. Education allows patients to reframe their treatment needs away from solely tissue-focused and passively received interventions. Explaining the neuroscience of pain has actually been shown to improve pain, movement and fear-avoidance,36 especially when provided with active strategies such as encouraging the patient to gradually resume normal activities in a paced manner and assistance with sleep disturbance.
Ultimately, non-drug interventions have the potential to improve outcomes for chronic pain and comorbidities4 and tend to be low-tech, low-cost and low-risk. GPs can deliver multimodal care themselves in micro-interventions over multiple consultations.7,37 They can supplement their patient care with workbook and online programs (see Box) or may collaborate with or refer to allied health providers.
Box - Pain management resources
Australian Pain Management Association. Pacing activity. Brisbane: APMA; 2015. [cited 2018 Mar 27]
Sleep restriction therapy. San Jose, CA: Kaiser Permanente; 2006. [PDF] [cited 2018 Mar 27]
Pain intensity, Enjoyment of life, General activity (PEG) assessment tool. [PDF] [cited 2018 Mar 27]
Faculty of Pain Medicine, Australian and New Zealand College of Anaesthetists. Better pain management: pain education for professionals. [Twelve brief online education modules] [cited 2018 Mar 27]
Pain Management Research Institute, University of Sydney. Webinar skills training in pain management: putting cognitive behavioural therapy skills into practice. [Online, interactive webinars training in CGT skills for pain] [cited 2018 Mar 27]
Non-pharmacological management of chronic pain. Presented by the Black Dog Institute [recorded webinar]. [cited 2018 Mar 27]
Davies S, Cooke N, Sutton J. Rewire your pain: an evidence based approach to reduce chronic pain. Brisbane: Australian Pain Management Association; 2015.
Nicholas M, Molloy A, Tonkin L, Beeston L. Manage your pain: practical and positive ways of adapting to chronic pain. 3rd ed. Sydney: Harper Collins Publishers Australia; 2011.
Edelman S. Change your thinking with CBT: overcome stress, combat anxiety and improve your life. London: Ebury Publishing; 2006.
Pain Management Network. Sydney: Agency for Clinical Innovation; 2018. [cited 2018 Mar 27]
painHEALTH. Easing musculoskeletal pain. Perth: painHEALTH; 2017. [cited 2018 Mar 27]
Patient online training in cognitive behaviour therapy for pain
The program 'This Way Up' seeks to reproduce training provided at a multidisciplinary clinic. It costs $59 for eight lessons and participants may access it over a year. Participants need to be referred by a registered clinician who can then receive feedback about their patients’ progress.
The MindSpot Pain Course is free and is accessible without a referral. It provides five mental health self-help lessons over two months with weekly support from a therapist. A YouTube introduction is available.
Brainman brief educational videos
Understanding pain in less than 5 minutes, and what to do about it! 2013 Jan 15. [cited 2018 Mar 27]
Understanding Pain: Brainman stops his opioids. 2014 Oct 3. [cited 2017 Mar 27]
Understanding Pain: Brainman chooses. 2014 Oct 3. [cited 2017 Mar 27]
Establishing safe, consistent patterns of movement can calm nervous system arousal and reduce central sensitisation.38,39 This can be facilitated by negotiating treatment goals that reflect meaningful and enjoyable activities, not just pain relief. Goals should be achievable and measurable with activities starting well below what the patient can do before gradually building their functional capacity. For example, sit-to-stand exercises can be used as the basis of a simple home-based strength program, starting from a raised seat height to reduce effort. Activity pacing and graded exercise avoids the ‘boom then bust’ trap and helps reduce pain, fatigue and depression.4
Pacing encourages patients to maintain relatively constant daily activity despite their pain levels. This means capping activity at the daily goal when pain is mild and using self-management strategies to increase activity to the daily goal when pain is more severe. Rotating time-limited activities decreases the frequency and often the intensity of pain flare ups and potential recourse to opioids.40 Behavioural activation, delivered by clinicians without specialist training, may also improve depression as effectively as formal cognitive behavioural therapy.41
It is important to explore any cognitive, behavioural and affective factors contributing to pain and suffering. Clinicians can help patients to recognise and modify unhelpful cognitions such as catastrophising, ‘black and white’ thinking and beliefs that drive fear-avoidance behaviours.15,42,43 It is critical to identify and treat depression or anxiety.42 Treatments include encouraging the scheduling of pleasurable activities, relaxation and exercise based on pacing principles. Antidepressants that may have an impact on pain include duloxetine and low-dose amitriptyline. Relaxation strategies, mindfulness, self-awareness and non-judgemental acceptance can help to self-regulate distress in the presence of pain.42 As well as directly supporting pain self-management, calming the nervous system and mind assists in alleviating insomnia and anxiety.
Patients frequently report using tobacco, cannabis and alcohol as a coping strategy.22 Despite the perception of short-term relief, these substances retard function by disturbing learning, memory and sleep architecture.22 For insomnia, first-line management involves cognitive behavioural strategies including sleep or bedtime restriction, avoiding screens before bedtime and other sleep hygiene measures.44
People typically feel safe when socially well connected and feel under threat when isolated. Meaningful positive social engagement at work or home is crucial for pain recovery. For example, the pain threshold is elevated when sharing a laugh with friends.45 Partners may aid recovery by being goal-oriented and by avoiding being unreasonably critical or over-solicitous. When sexual intimacy has been lost, re-establishing it may require an adaptation of activity pacing known as sensate focusing.46
As with other chronic metabolic illnesses, obesity is frequently associated with chronic pain.47 The gut microbial profile or microbiome has been hypothesised to be the nexus between the Western diet and the maladaptations in the nervous, immune and endocrine systems.48 These may interlink with a low-grade inflammatory state (metaflammation).34 Simple nutritional interventions for pain encourage consuming five serves of vegetables per day and two of fruit while reducing intake of sugary and processed foods.34
Long-term opioid therapy for analgesia is a surrogate for simplistic conceptualisations of pain and leads to inadequate pain management.7 Effective care includes moving beyond a focus on pain relief and prescribing drugs. To do this, clinicians need to be familiar with the alternatives and become confident in their use so they can help patients to understand the benefits of deprescribing. However, some patients will require opioid substitution therapy.
A medical system that rewards rapid patient throughput, subsidises opioid analgesics, and focuses on ‘quick fixes’ will never untangle the many strands of suffering contributing to chronic pain. We need to give our patients hope for wellness and some sense of control over their adversity. Opioid deprescribing together with multimodal measures will improve individual and public health, and reduce chronic pain and associated comorbidities.4,26
Conflicts of interest: Chris Hayes has undertaken sponsored consultancy and educational work with Mundipharma, Janssen and Pfizer prior to 2013. Newman Harris declares payments for services from Mundipharma, Janssen and Pfizer. Michael Nicholas receives royalties from a book listed in the Box (Manage your Pain).
Acknowledgement: The authors would like to acknowledge the contributions of Cathy Fraser and Parker Magin.
Staff specialist, Drug and Alcohol Clinical Services, Hunter New England Local Health District, Newcastle, NSW
General practitioner, Albert St Medical Centre, Taree, NSW
Specialist pain medicine physician, Hunter Integrated Pain Service, John Hunter
Pain educator and PhD candidate, Discipline of Physiotherapy, Judith Lumley Centre, La Trobe University, Melbourne
Associate professor in medical education (retired), University of Sydney
General practitioner, Lindfield, NSW
Consultant psychiatrist and Specialist pain medicine physician, Royal North Shore Hospital, Sydney
Clinical senior lecturer, Pain Management Research Institute, Northern Clinical School, University of Sydney
Clinical psychologist, Royal North Shore Hospital, Sydney
Professor and Director, Pain Education Unit, Pain Management Research Institute, Northern Clinical School, University of Sydney