A one-year trial randomised 781 patients with primary insomnia to take suvorexant or a placebo.3 Patients over 65 years took 30 mg and other patients took 40 mg. After a year, the 322 patients still taking suvorexant either continued it or were switched to placebo. All the patients kept a diary about their sleep. At the start of the study, the patients in the placebo group said it was taking them 65 minutes to get to sleep and they slept for an average of 330 minutes. The corresponding figures for the suvorexant group were 66 minutes and 320 minutes. When efficacy was assessed over a month the suvorexant group was getting to sleep 18 minutes sooner on average and sleeping for 39 minutes longer than before. These benefits were maintained for the patients who continued treatment for one year. There were no statistically significant differences in symptoms when suvorexant was withdrawn, but the time to sleep onset increased and the total sleep time decreased.3
During the one-year trial approximately 38% of the suvorexant and placebo groups did not complete the study. Adverse events caused 11.7% of the patients taking suvorexant and 8.5% of the placebo group to discontinue. Somnolence affected 13.2% of the patients taking suvorexant but only 2.7% of the placebo group. Other adverse effects which were more frequent with suvorexant were fatigue, dry mouth, dyspepsia and peripheral oedema. Although there was no overall effect on mood, four patients taking suvorexant developed suicidal ideation. Uncommon adverse effects, such as sleep walking, sleep paralysis and hallucinations, were also only reported in the suvorexant group.3
For a hypnotic, suvorexant has a long half-life. Although most patients are not affected, some will have residual effects the next day. They should therefore not drive or operate machinery if they are not fully alert. Alcohol and other drugs that depress the central nervous system should be avoided. The safety of suvorexant in pregnancy and lactation is unknown. Patients with neurological or psychiatric disorders were excluded from the trials.2,3 Suvorexant is contraindicated in narcolepsy.
It should be noted that some of the clinical trials used doses that were higher than the doses approved for use in Australia (15 mg and 20 mg). The higher doses had more adverse effects, but the efficacy of suvorexant at lower doses seems modest. In a systematic review, the differences for suvorexant 15 or 20 mg compared with placebo, after three months of treatment, were six minutes for the time to fall asleep and 16 minutes for total sleep time. Thirteen patients need to be treated for one to have a 15% subjective improvement in total sleep time. As 26 would need to be treated for a 15% improvement in the time to sleep onset, this effect is not significant. The systematic review says that for every 28 people taking suvorexant 15 or 20 mg, one would experience somnolence as an adverse event.4
While suvorexant may be better than placebo, how it compares with other hypnotics is uncertain. Dependence is less likely to be a problem compared to benzodiazepines, but caution is advised when prescribing suvorexant to people with a history of drug abuse. If a hypnotic is required, suvorexant should not be taken for more than three months without the indication being reviewed.